Butler Looks Sharp, Abell Gets Rocked

Raphael Butler sealed a shot at highly ranked contender “Fast” Eddie Chambers by TKOing journeyman Otis Tisdale in the fourth round Saturday night.  Action was said to be slow for the first three, picking up in the fourth when Tisdale tried to to go toe-to-toe with Butler and consequently got the worst of the exchange.  Butler ripped Tisdale against the ropes until referee Mark Nelson stopped the fight.

By contrast, Joey Abell suffered a career setback when he was stopped by Andrew Greeley in a shocker.  Abell was looking good and in control, and decided to go for the kill. Abell landed some good punches but then got caught.  A Greeley right put Abell down and through the ropes.  Abell got up in time but was unable to adequately defend himself, taking a couple more power shots after the knockdown.  Mark Nelson stopped the fight with two seconds left in the fourth.  There is bound to be criticism of Nelson for stopping this one as he did, but any criticism is unfair.   Nelson is an excellent ref, probably the best in Minnesota.  And one cannot expect a referee to be watching the clock when a fighter is in trouble.

While Butler (now 31-4) trains for a fight with Chambers in the Cayman Islands June 20, Abell (now 20-2) will most likely be looking at some more bouts in Philadelphia as he tries to improve his ranking and reputation following this difficult loss.  Abell may take some consolation in the example of the great Harry Greb, a old-time boxer who had some difficult losses (some awful beatings, in fact) early in his career but learned from them, eventually becoming one of the all-time greats and retiring with a career record of 260-21.


4 responses to “Butler Looks Sharp, Abell Gets Rocked

  1. Harry Greb had awful beatings?
    I’d like to know what your referring to?

  2. Against Mike Gibbons on 2-10-17, according to the Warren Evening Times “Gibbons boxed cleverly and kept nailing Harry with stiff jabs. In the 6th round, Mike became aggressive and landed repeatedly to head and body.” Against Tommy Gibbons on 11-16-15, according to the Pittsburgh Post, “Tommy gave Harry a real beating in the 9th and 10th. Greb was in tough shape at the end of the 9th after taking a terrific overhand right, followed by a two-handed battering.” See boxrec.com for more details.

  3. The Mike Gibbons 6 Rnder was in Phili.
    I have all the Phili write ups. It doesn’t describe an awful beating to my mind.

  4. big ed, I’m not going to argue the finer points of a fight that took place 93 years ago and which neither of us ever saw. If you want a different example, use this one from 5-15-1920: “Newspaper win for [Tommy] Gibbons according to the Pittsburgh Post. Greb ‘took the licking of his life.’ Gibbons won 7 rounds, Greb only two (narrowly), and the third round was even. ‘Gibbons astonished the fans with the speed and accuracy of his punches, and his ability to make Harry miss and look bad.'” That was from the prime of Greb’s career. Greb beat Gibbons several times afterwards, and the point remains: fighters can learn from losing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s